The Top Spots For Pie In Aurora

Village Inn | Directions

Known nationwide for its pies, this diner-style restaurant has long been a go-to destination for anyone craving a slice of classic American dessert. There are several Village Inn locations throughout Aurora, making it easy to stop in for a slice no matter where you are in the city. The French Silk Pie is especially popular, featuring a rich chocolate filling in a flaky crust topped with whipped cream. It’s the perfect indulgent treat to celebrate March 14.

Must-try pies:

• French Silk Pie
• Coconut Cream Pie
• Country Apple Pie

Black Bear Diner | Directions

If you’re craving a classic, oversized slice of pie, Black Bear Diner is a great stop. Known for its cozy cabin-style atmosphere and hearty comfort food, this diner also serves up generous slices of traditional American pies. From fruit-filled favorites to rich cream pies, the dessert case here feels like a throwback to old-school diner baking, making it perfect for celebrating Pi Day with a fork and a big appetite.

Must-try pies:

• Homemade Chocolate Cream Pie
• Homemade Banana Cream Pie
• Homemade Coconut Cream Pie

Daniel's of Paris | Directions

For a more artisanal take on pie, stop by Daniel's of Paris, a longtime Aurora bakery known for its French-inspired pastries, cakes, and classic desserts. Alongside their beautifully crafted baked goods, the bakery also offers a selection of traditional pies that make a great Pi Day treat. Depending on the day and season, you may find favorites like apple, cherry, pecan, or lemon meringue pies available, with some varieties offered for pre-order. If you’re looking for a slice that feels a little more handcrafted and bakery-style than diner pie, Daniel’s of Paris is a great stop.

Must-try pies:

• Apple Crumb Pie
• Cherry Pie
• Lemon Meringue Pie

Famous Dave's - Baker Square Pies | Directions

While Famous Dave’s is best known for its barbecue, it’s also a great spot to grab a slice of pie! The restaurant pairs slow-smoked meats with classic Southern sides like mac & cheese, baked beans, cornbread, and coleslaw. After enjoying a hearty BBQ meal, you can finish your Pi Day celebration with a slice of Baker’s Square pie. Whether you dine in or take a pie to go, Famous Dave’s offers the perfect combination of savory and sweet for a truly satisfying Pi Day experience.

Must-try pies:

• French Silk Pie
• Lemon Supreme Pie
• Southern Pecan Pie
• Country Apple Pie

Lazy Dog | Directions

For a cozy, comfort-food take on pie, stop by Lazy Dog Restaurant & Bar. Known for its lodge-style atmosphere and hearty American menu, Lazy Dog also serves a standout dessert that’s perfect for Pi Day. Their Apple-Huckleberry Open Face Pie features warm cinnamon apples and wild huckleberries topped with salted caramel and a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream, all nestled in a hand-folded sugar pie crust. It’s a sweet, shareable way to end a meal and a delicious excuse to celebrate 3.14.

Must-try pies:

• Apple-Huckleberry Open Face Pie

Cuba Bakery & Cafe | Directions

Another beloved dessert destination is Cuba Bakery & Café. This neighborhood bakery offers an incredible selection of Latin American desserts, pastries, and sweet treats. While not a traditional pie shop, many of their fruit-filled and cream desserts deliver the same satisfying flavors pie lovers crave.

Must-try desserts:

• Guava and Cheese Pastry
• Guava Pastry
• Cheese Pastry 
• All feature fruit or creamy fillings encased in a flaky crust, perfect for Pi Day.

Because Pizza Counts Too

Pi Day isn’t only about sweet desserts! Pizza pies deserve their moment, too! Check out our pizza blog for a complete list of the top pizza spots in Aurora.

Heros Pizzeria & Tavern | Directions

Check out Hero's Pizzeria & Tavern for a top hangout spot. Featuring your favorite cheesy pies, wings, and pasta, visitors taste through the best bites. Try their famous Hero's Pizza featuring pepperoni, spicy sausage, green pepper, and mozzarella; your taste buds will thank you! This is another spot to watch sports, play pool, and catch up with friends over delicious slices. 

Pizza's to try:

• Hero’s Pizza
• Hero’s Deluxe Pizza
• The Sicilian Pizza

Pizza 72 | Directions

A family-owned & operated pizza joint that has been delivering flavorful recipes since 1972. They boast, "not all cheese & toppings are the same. We choose quality over price." One bite & you’ll fall in love with your slice. Try their thick crust Sicilian for a trip to the "old country". They also offer gluten-free options!

Pizza's to try:

• Pizza 72 Special
• 5-Meat Pizza
• BBQ Chicken Pizza
• Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Looking for more restaurants in Aurora? Check out Visit Aurora’s Restaurant Page